New Sticky Note

NOTICE: This league is using the BLEEDING EDGE game engine. For more information, click here.

The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

League Forums

Main - Bug Box

Re: Safety Ignored

By Ares
4/13/2015 3:15 am
1-10-SOU 0 (12:01) 40-Ronald Smith ran for -1 yards. Tackle by 35-Tony Baker. SAFETY! (35-Tony Baker) PENALTY - Holding (SOU 69-Darrell Roldan) (Declined)1-11-SOU 0 (12:01) 40-Ronald Smith ran for -1 yards. Tackle by 35-Tony Baker. SAFETY! (35-Tony Baker) PENALTY - Holding (SOU 69-Darrell Roldan)

http://cust10.myfootballnow.com/watch/370#71276

The down was then replayed.
Last edited at 4/14/2015 4:11 pm

Re: Safety Ignored

By Gustoon - League Admin
4/13/2015 3:29 am
Maybe somehow that holding call screwed the AI up some how?? Odd though

Re: Safety Ignored

By Gustoon - League Admin
4/14/2015 1:17 pm
Just had one of my own.
We punt to their 1 yd line, 2 plays later with no gain from the other play, we make a tackle for -2 yds and no safety given?

Re: Safety Ignored

By jdavidbakr - Site Admin
4/14/2015 1:25 pm
Gustoon wrote:
Just had one of my own.
We punt to their 1 yd line, 2 plays later with no gain from the other play, we make a tackle for -2 yds and no safety given?


Please post a link to this play as well. Thanks!

Re: Safety Ignored

By Gustoon - League Admin
4/14/2015 3:00 pm
jdavidbakr wrote:
Gustoon wrote:
Just had one of my own.
We punt to their 1 yd line, 2 plays later with no gain from the other play, we make a tackle for -2 yds and no safety given?


Please post a link to this play as well. Thanks!


Sorry my bad - http://cust12.myfootballnow.com/watch/294#63085

When I watch games, I watch them from quite a wide angle and didn't see that the ball is actually spotted at about 1.5, so the call was at the 1, but actually its more like 1.5, but then the tackle for loss is -2, so confusingly this must also be a loss of 1.5 and not 2 *scratches head*

Re: Safety Ignored

By martinwarnett
4/14/2015 3:44 pm
Gustoon wrote:
jdavidbakr wrote:
Gustoon wrote:
Just had one of my own.
We punt to their 1 yd line, 2 plays later with no gain from the other play, we make a tackle for -2 yds and no safety given?


Please post a link to this play as well. Thanks!


Sorry my bad - http://cust12.myfootballnow.com/watch/294#63085

When I watch games, I watch them from quite a wide angle and didn't see that the ball is actually spotted at about 1.5, so the call was at the 1, but actually its more like 1.5, but then the tackle for loss is -2, so confusingly this must also be a loss of 1.5 and not 2 *scratches head*


Guess; rounding error.

Ball at 1.5; so listed as 2nd and whatever at 1 yd line.
Tackle for loss of say 1.25 yds; rounded up to be a loss of -2?

Re: Safety Ignored

By Gustoon - League Admin
4/14/2015 3:53 pm
martinwarnett wrote:
Gustoon wrote:
jdavidbakr wrote:
Gustoon wrote:
Just had one of my own.
We punt to their 1 yd line, 2 plays later with no gain from the other play, we make a tackle for -2 yds and no safety given?


Please post a link to this play as well. Thanks!


Sorry my bad - http://cust12.myfootballnow.com/watch/294#63085

When I watch games, I watch them from quite a wide angle and didn't see that the ball is actually spotted at about 1.5, so the call was at the 1, but actually its more like 1.5, but then the tackle for loss is -2, so confusingly this must also be a loss of 1.5 and not 2 *scratches head*


Guess; rounding error.

Ball at 1.5; so listed as 2nd and whatever at 1 yd line.
Tackle for loss of say 1.25 yds; rounded up to be a loss of -2?


Its a bit confusing (and annoying) when you think you've got the break you need only to have it taken away. I wish that these down markings were more accurate.

Re: Safety Ignored

By martinwarnett
4/14/2015 4:54 pm
Where the down is spotted should always be the driver. The play result should be as accurate as possible within reason.

Where the ball is spotted on the 1.5 yd line, listed as 1 yd line with the play claiming to lose 2 yards - you think safety.

If the ball was at the 1.5yd line then list it as that. If the play lost 1.25 yards either list it as so or round the loss down to 1 yd. Rounding down would lead to less confusion - you'd obviously not think loss of a yard then on the 1.5 could ever be a safety.

Re: Safety Ignored

By jdavidbakr - Site Admin
4/14/2015 7:26 pm
That's a good guess with the rounding, and was my first thought as well, although it would be tough for a rounding error to give that result - it does round to the nearest, so 1.25 rounds to 1.

What _did_ happen is actually a known bug that has been fixed in version 0.3 - the game correctly gives the runner forward progress, but the play-by-play calls it as down where the play actually stopped. This has been fixed but I didn't back-port it into 0.2.2.
Last edited at 4/14/2015 7:26 pm

Re: Safety Ignored

By mrfakename
4/14/2015 9:43 pm
I see nothing wrong in general because of forward progress or rounding but the placement of the ball after the original tackle for loss is off. Basing this off of the blue line of scrimmage without forward progress. The ball is 11 inches long, the closest it can be placed is like at the 0.3 yard line about the same width as the neutral zone on any given play. Any stop closer than that would be a safety, because a part of the ball would be on the goaline.