NOTICE: This league is using the BLEEDING EDGE game engine. For more information, click here.

The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

NOTE: As of the last sim, this league was under the minimum 20% capacity. Invite your friends to join MyFootballNow to keep this league alive! Then send them to this league to become the owner of a team! The league will expire at 1/17/2025 8:00 am.

League Forums

Main - Suggestion Box

Depth chart improvement idea

By Lunkan
10/31/2018 8:38 am
It's hard to keep order of players' SECONDARY - and third- fourth :) - useable positions, extra much when playing more than one league.

Extra much wanted :) by the sim play players to much, who are ment only to be used in THAT position IF better players get injuried, but the coach can want to play them in OTHER position so it can't be solved by making them inactive....
Because without this suggestion it's much work if take them away from backup positions where they are bad but not terrible :) when they become needed the be active in secondary backup positions by the better players there get injuried. Much work to look through many players to check again who can be backups there during the injuries...

So it would be convinient if it would become possible to KEEP a player in Depth chart in positions where they are not even second backup, but make them passive in THAT position, but stiill active in OTHER position.
Preferingly geting other color when they are "half passive".

Re: Depth chart improvement idea

By wieczoreks
11/02/2018 11:10 pm
That simply isn't how football works. You can only dress 46 guys on gameday, so on a full 53-man roster, 7 guys are inactive (i.e. ineligible to play).

You can put the same player at multiple positions in varying orders. Not sure why you need them inactive at one position but active at another.

Re: Depth chart improvement idea

By preshead
11/03/2018 7:01 pm
I’m not sure if I’m having a similar idea to Lunkin...

Perhaps he’s trying to say, if your LT gets injured, by default his backup begins playing. But if you want your LG to move to LT and then your LG backup becomes your actively playing LG, how do you control that? Even if you put your LG as your backup at LT, will it move the LG to LT instead of keeping him at his starting position at LG? How do you control the shifting around of offensive linemen to what you want?

If this can’t be controlled, is it just a case of hoping the head coach will do what you want?

Re: Depth chart improvement idea

By jlyman
11/04/2018 1:39 pm
Maybe it would work by putting your starting LG at the #2 position at LT. Then if your LT gets hurt and has to leave the game your LT#2 is your LG#1. Moving the LG#2 to the starting position at guard.

Re: Depth chart improvement idea

By shauma_llama
11/05/2018 12:22 am
Boom/Bust

Allow that as a search criteria. I was looking at various free-agents, and noticed someone had a cut a player whose improvement so far, in his rookie season, was +5/+14 (something like that). I signed him straight away. Then I thought "why can't I search by this?"
Last edited at 11/05/2018 12:24 am

Re: Depth chart improvement idea

By Lunkan
11/05/2018 7:48 pm
wieczoreks wrote:
That simply isn't how football works. You can only dress 46 guys on gameday, so on a full 53-man roster, 7 guys are inactive (i.e. ineligible to play).
You missunderstood my idea.
wieczoreks wrote:
You can put the same player at multiple positions in varying orders. Not sure why you need them inactive at one position but active at another.
Because to assist to REMEMBER which players can functions as BACKUPS at some more positions than their main position, when players get injuried so they can't participate in NEXT match.
=These backups AREN'T expected to be needed as backups during the RUNNING match, and because they aren't so good, I don't want to play them in THAT position THAT game.
But by injuries (or it can be trades and such too) a Depth Chart can need some change to NEXT match. Then it would be convinient to not need to check through several players, who can be of some use in that position, when it's "crisis" by many injuries at SAME position.
If make it possible to have them at the Depth Chart and active at SOME ppsitions they are put at, it would become less work to keep order of where players can play as secomdary positions.
It become extra hard to remember such things when having more than one team and players in different teams have similar names :)

For instance in some teams I have punt/kick return "specialists" which aren't so good in any other position, but they can be better than no one :) if geting many injuries in a position they can play at.
At same time I DON'T want to have them "active" in BOTH positions, when there are no injuries there, because the others are so much better... :)
Soon after I started playing I noticed the sim engine play players I didn't expected to be used EXCEPT at injuries, but the 3-4-5 backup were played WITHOUT there were injuries. So I "had to" take them away at THAT position, but I can STILL want to use them in Special teams...

IRL a coach have such in his head, but he spend much more time at his ONE team, than I spend at my FIVE teams in this GAME :) That's why I would find it convinient with such assistance.

Re: Depth chart improvement idea

By Lunkan
11/05/2018 7:52 pm
preshead wrote:
I’m not sure if I’m having a similar idea to Lunkin...

Perhaps he’s trying to say, if your LT gets injured, by default his backup begins playing. But if you want your LG to move to LT and then your LG backup becomes your actively playing LG, how do you control that? Even if you put your LG as your backup at LT, will it move the LG to LT instead of keeping him at his starting position at LG? How do you control the shifting around of offensive linemen to what you want?

If this can’t be controlled, is it just a case of hoping the head coach will do what you want?
That's an OTHER idea than mine.
Yours is DURING a match,
mine is to be used BETWEEN matches when a situation have changed much since the preparing for the match before,

Re: Depth chart improvement idea

By Lunkan
11/05/2018 8:00 pm
shauma_llama wrote:
Boom/Bust

Allow that as a search criteria. I was looking at various free-agents, and noticed someone had a cut a player whose improvement so far, in his rookie season, was +5/+14 (something like that). I signed him straight away. Then I thought "why can't I search by this?"
Yes. that would be nice.

Your text inspred me :) to get the idea this can be used to solve BOTH these:
I were going to suggest the following also :) although to find who to pick to positions as Kick returner and Kick holder which is very inconvinient as it is now to find among the player who ARE in the team allready.

SAME search function as in Free agents, but for players in the team allready , can solve BOTH these things in ONE solution.
Last edited at 11/05/2018 8:04 pm

Re: Depth chart improvement idea

By jlyman
11/05/2018 10:49 pm
You can select your own team in the player search in order to find the best players at certain positions. I do this all the time to fill out my depth chart.

Re: Depth chart improvement idea

By wieczoreks
11/06/2018 8:11 am
Lunkan wrote:
At same time I DON'T want to have them "active" in BOTH positions, when there are no injuries there, because the others are so much better... :)
Soon after I started playing I noticed the sim engine play players I didn't expected to be used EXCEPT at injuries, but the 3-4-5 backup were played WITHOUT there were injuries. So I "had to" take them away at THAT position, but I can STILL want to use them in Special teams...

Then that's your actual problem. I list 5 or more players at every position in my depth chart, because you are right, it is hard to remember who is good at backup when planning for next game when you have many teams. This has never caused a problem for me. I rarely see the computer play players that aren't either the primary or backup for that position. In the early days I downloaded the game log. I filtered and checked who was in game each play to understand how/when the computer made subs.