NOTICE: This league is using the BLEEDING EDGE game engine. For more information, click here.

The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

NOTE: As of the last sim, this league was under the minimum 20% capacity. Invite your friends to join MyFootballNow to keep this league alive! Then send them to this league to become the owner of a team! The league will expire at 1/17/2025 8:00 am.

League Forums

Main - Community Help Forum

Questionable vs Probable

By CoachSimpson
5/13/2019 3:41 am
I didn't grow up with this kind of football.....I wonder what the difference is between these 2 types of injuries; questionable vs probable?

When is the player a fuzzy pants and when is he actually injured? When to sit him out, really?

Re: Questionable vs Probable

By Lamba
5/13/2019 3:54 am
Check the health tab.

Generally, when players are fit, there's no injury designation. From there, I think it's:

Probable
Questionable
Doubtful
Out

Generally, you'll mostly be alright playing with players with probable. Questionable is exactly that. If it's your one star tight end in a very important game, you might want to risk him.

Doubtful is pretty much "Sure, we could shove this guy out of the weelchair and suit him up. Whether he's able to do much more than stand there is the question...".

Re: Questionable vs Probable

By CoachSimpson
5/13/2019 5:07 am
Thanks :)

Doubtful is pretty much "Sure, we could shove this guy out of the weelchair and suit him up. Whether he's able to do much more than stand there is the question...".


Just standing there seems like what most of the team are doing sometimes, anyway :D

Re: Questionable vs Probable

By Lamba
5/13/2019 5:45 am
No problem. The short version is: If they have an injury designation, they're injured.

It's up to you how you manage the injuries. Personally, I move a probable RB down in the depth chart to limit his exposure, but if it's a key position or a key matchup (like my coming against LAA), I might keep my probable key players active.

Re: Questionable vs Probable

By mmr253
5/13/2019 5:51 am
I'll generally only consider playing Probable players if their injury bar is around 75 unless they have injuries in two places then I'll keep them out until fully healed.
I should stress this is personal preference rather than being based on any evidence.
This changes for playoff games or important matchups during the season when I'd play them sooner.
Last edited at 5/13/2019 5:52 am

Re: Questionable vs Probable

By raymattison21
5/13/2019 6:19 am
I play the ratings. Each injury is designated to an area of the body. Pending how bad each category is effecting play per positions demands . A rb will be more effectively neutered if he has a leg and or ankle injury that puts him at a field speed below what your scheme requires.

Each body part can reduce the players relevant ratings 25% if they are at zero . A low number in any body will put him in at least a doubtful label.

Imo this is where it get interesting . A 100 speed back with 2 injuries at 50 to his leg and ankle will now have 75 speed. Idk is that still effective ? Most likely not but if it s the big game and your back up only has 70 speed healthy ....I would go with the injured guy, but might limit his snaps .

Another possibility is an LG hurts those same two body parts, but he has 10 speed. Calculating ....now he has 8 speed. Not a big deal in my offensive scheme...it wouldn't matter at any speed really unless my back up was better/healthier. If if we're his hand or neck I would sit that same player ....pending his matchup (Dt) for that game...but I consider a few other things as well.



I had a TE who was severely injured 3 or 4 times and had 5 or 6 other ones in 1 and half seasons of play .. but......he only missed 2 games. I played him till he could walk. ......here comes another layer.... the next season he was still injured. There wasn't enough off season to completelyheal him.

As one injury happens and the player is played there is an increased chance of another injury. So pending on the players particular in game demands , his age, how quickly he is healing, and another is his conditioning as that moderates injuries too. This kind of creates an injury prone label for certain over used and under healed players.

Say I get an elite boomer in the draft and he gets hurt in pre-season game one....almost every time he sits until his body parts are completely healed. Not when the game labels him as healthy . ..when his body part is 100. As I don't want a serious injury this early in his career

If it were the regular season and I needed a win I might play this guy....or if he were a qb (they don't get injuries as much) same, but I save that risk if it is a contract renegotiation year or if he has chance to retire coming up. Just trying to prevent that injury prone label if I have to pay alot to retain him. Or help boost unseen trade value, but thats not directly effectived as injuries are random..?.?.

That TE was in his 12th year and I knew I would get him for the league minimum next season so who cares . But my elite booming 2 yr wr suffered alot less injuries sat plenty in comparison . Say that wr was in his 8th or 9th season he be playing more while injured.

I not saying to ignore the labels , but I see them then check what body was actually injuried . Parabolizing ratings has created more chances for injuries so this layer of the game has recently become more important . The safe bet is to have some depth anyway, cause the players fatigue levels moderate injuries as well.

In the nfl these label are required to be put on all player who were said to be injured . Sometimes Teams will paint a loose picture of what actually happened to the player in order to throw off opponents . Its i llegal but bending the truth in the nfl is ok at times till you get caught.

But most guys are playing with some type of injury at all times but not receive a label. We here get to see those kicked up players to the detail. So probable and questionable are interchangable to me . Like a no label here, but he's an 88 at neck, that almost questionable pending on my team/situation . Definitely closer to a probable imo.

No label, but still slightly injured - be careful here...theyou are not fully healed yet

Probable- like a no label injury to me , but I depends on demands , game, age

Questionable -this is where I highly consider sitting younger players but not old, same for individual matchups it depends

Doubtful - I play guys here rarely , but watch this will get labeled as a concussion , but the guy will be unable to play . ...Possibly resetting game plans if you play this guy in the playoffs with much worse results .

Out- these guys sometimes heal quicker than the designated time frame. I like to give a game or two rested before I put them on the ir if it is later in the season to see if they might be able to come back healthy enough to contribute before the seasons end.

Re: Questionable vs Probable

By CoachSimpson
5/13/2019 7:07 am
Thanks all - still have a lot to learn....getting there eventually

Re: Questionable vs Probable

By CrazySexyBeast
5/14/2019 8:48 pm
Great post, ray.
All I can add is that knowing if it was the L or R hand/arm and what "handedness" the player is would be a nifty add.
A right hand dominant QB/RB with an injury to the left hand is not nearly as big a deal as it would be if it were his R hand.
I dunno, I think it would be a very neat add, help make playing decisions (meh it's my center's nondominant hand), and add a subtle layer to the game for us junkies.